By: Angela Zhang
Why is it that in the 2016 election, Hillary Clinton won the national popular vote by nearly three million votes, yet Donald Trump won the presidency? Or in 2000, why is it that when Al Gore received more popular votes than George W. Bush, he still lost the presidency? 1
Trump and Bush were the winners of the elections because they won the Electoral College. What is the Electoral College, and is it an outdated system of electing the president?
What Is the Electoral College?
In the United States, we do not elect the president and vice president directly through a nationwide popular vote. Rather, there is an Electoral College system in which each state has electors that select the president. Each state receives a certain number of electoral votes that is equal to its total number in Congress: two senators plus its number of House of Representatives members. 2,3
The possible electors in the Electoral College are selected by political parties. They are trusted people who could be a longtime member of the political party, a state party leader, a former elected mayor or state legislator, or someone who has contributed significantly to the party. 4. When voters choose their preferred presidential candidate on Election Day, they are also voting for that candidate's group of electors.
This system was established by the Constitution in 1787 as a compromise between having Congress elect the president and having the citizens elect the president. The Founding Fathers wanted to balance the influence of large and small states and to address concerns of the public's access to political information and their ability to make informed decisions about the candidates. However, its original purpose 240 years ago might not remain the best method of choosing the nation's leader today.
In favor of the Electoral College
Supporters of the Electoral College argue that it gives smaller states greater influence in presidential elections and prevents presidential candidates from focusing exclusively on the most populous states. Because every state receives two electoral votes for its senators, states with smaller populations receive proportionally more electoral votes per resident.
The Electoral College also encourages candidates to appeal to voters across different regions. A presidential candidate must build support in enough states to win the Electoral College, rather than simply winning the largest number of votes in a few heavily populated areas.
In opposition to the Electoral College
The strongest argument against the Electoral College is that it undermines political equality. The Electoral College can produce a president who received fewer votes nationwide than the opposing candidate. It explains how, despite Clinton receiving more national popular votes in 2016, Trump still became the president after winning the Electoral College. And how Al Gore won the popular vote in 2000, but Bush won the presidency. 1. The Electoral College’s ability to override the national popular vote raises concerns about whether it adequately represents the will of the people.
Another problem is that candidates will focus on competitive swing states such as Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, and Georgia because their electoral votes can determine the outcome of an election. Meanwhile, voters in states that consistently favor one political party may receive far less attention. As a result, millions of Americans who live in predictable states have less influence on the final electoral outcome. 5
Additionally, the Electoral College reinforces the two-party system by favoring the Democratic and Republican parties over smaller political parties. It makes it extremely difficult for third-party candidates to gain enough electoral votes to win the presidency, even if they receive millions of votes nationwide. Consequently, voters may avoid supporting third-party candidates out of fear that their votes will be wasted.
What Would Elections Look Like Without the Electoral College?
Abolishing the Electoral College system would be difficult since it is a constitutional amendment and would require approval by two-thirds of both chambers of Congress and ratification by three-fourths of the states.
It would create new challenges. Candidates might focus heavily on large population centers, and a national popular vote could require new rules for recounts, election administration, and resolving extremely close elections. 5
However, a national popular vote system would guarantee that the candidate receiving the most votes nationwide becomes president, regardless of which states they won. Every vote would matter equally and contribute directly to the result. Candidates would have an incentive to appeal to voters throughout the country, rather than focusing on competitive swing states.
Conclusion
The Electoral College was established in early America to address the concerns of a young nation, but the United States has changed considerably since its founding, and its original purpose might not be the best method today. Ultimately, abolishing the Electoral College comes with challenges, but it would allow a more equal and representative method of electing the president, where every vote would contribute equally. Whether we should abolish the Electoral College should be evaluated to fit the modern political climate of America.
Citations
“America’s Electoral College and the Popular Vote.” The Economist, December 28, 2016. https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2016/12/28/americas-electoral-college-and-the-popular-vote.
United States. Constitution of the United States. Article V.
Garrett, Sam R. “The Electoral College: Frequently Asked Questions | Congress.Gov | Library of Congress.” congress.gov, May 5, 2026. https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R48936.
“About the Electors.” National Archives and Records Administration, November 7, 2024. https://www.archives.gov/electoral-college/electors.
Lempert, Richard, Roy Neel, Fred Wertheimer, et al. “It’s Time to Abolish the Electoral College.” Brookings, October 10, 2024. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/its-time-to-abolish-the-electoral-college/.